The Top 15 Beanie Babies of All Time

Have you ever questioned the value of the Ty Beanie Babies you keep on a shelf? More than some of the finest pieces of designer jewelry has been paid for the most expensive Beanie Babies.

Few people could have predicted how popular Ty Beanie Babies would become with collectors when they first debuted in 1993. By 1995, they had become popular among casual collectors, but their worth wasn’t discovered until the original toys were phased out.

The Top 15 Beanie Babies of All Time

Ty announced that they would stop producing Beanie Babies in 1999. But the charming toys were in demand thanks to collectors and casual admirers. Even if some Beanie Babies remained in retirement, they soon came back. It was only the beginning, beginning with “The Beginning,” a Beanie Baby released in 2000.

Ty Beanie Babies are continuously being added to the list. Casual fans, however, are more interested in recently released toys, while collectors are looking for rare, original Beanie Babies. Some people are just fervent about owning Beanie Babies that are worthwhile. Others are looking at Beanie Baby pricing guides in the hopes of finding a priceless childhood toy.

eBay auctions demonstrate the extent to which collectors will pay a premium for rare and authentic Ty Beanie Babies. The most expensive Beanie Babies have sold for more than numerous luxury watches combined, yet some only bring in a few hundred dollars.

Read More On: The 5 Best Baby Monitors 2022

The most costly Ty Beanie Babies ever sold, listed in order of least to most valued, will cost you in 2022.

15. Halo Bear: $7,500

A year later, in 1998, Halo Bears were made available. Halo initially didn’t stick out because it was already far into the Beanie Baby collecting mania. White bears with iridescent wings and a matching halo have white fur. This Ty Beanie Baby was well-liked because of its motivational poem, but it was discontinued after only a year. Halo Bears from the original run can cost up to $7,500.

51bOGo0fKtL. AC SL1000
  • Brand: Beanie baby
  • Animal theme Bear
  • Toy figure type Stuffed Toy
  • Material Plush
  • Cartoon Character Animal

14. McDonald’s International Bears: $10,000

Even the most devoted Ty Beanie Baby collectors might be surprised to find McDonald’s listed here. In the 1990s, Teenie Babies, or little Beanie Babies, were marketed alongside Happy Meals. The bears Britannia (Britain), Maple (Canada), Erin (Ireland), and Glory (Glory) each stand for a different nation (US). Up to $10,000 can be spent on a collection of Teenie Babies in their original packaging.

13. Claude the Crab: $9,000

Claude is a vibrant Beanie Baby with a tie-dye print in shades of blue, green, and orange. He immediately became a beloved Beanie Baby thanks to his little beaded eyes and vibrant physique. Ty aficionados love the 1997 release of the original Claude Beanie Babies. The little yet distinctive crab has been sold for $9,000 at auction.

41BC71B1Y0L. AC
  • Brand Beanie Babies – Sea Life
  • Toy figure type Stuffed Toy
  • Material Plush
  • Assembly Required No
  • Manufacturer Minimum Age 36.00

12. Garcia Bear: $10,000

Garcia Bear is pure entertainment, but few people realize its value. The Ty Beanie Baby is a multicolored bear with splotches of teal, red, and green. A classic face, black button eyes, and a yellow tummy make for an attractive combination. It was only manufactured for a brief period beginning in 1993, and many people had trouble locating one. First editions can sell for up to $10,000.

11. Iggy Iguana: $15,000

One of the most costly Ty Beanie Babies ever sold, Iggy the Iguana sold for $15,000, making him one of the most expensive ones ever. The challenge? A common mix-up involves Rainbow the Chameleon and Iggy the Iguana. Compared to Rainbow the Chameleon, Iggy has spikes along their back. A 1997 tag, which denotes the item’s initial release, is unusual and adds value to Iggy the Iguana.

10. Hope Bear: $15,000

This Ty Beanie Baby is not only costly but also extremely hard to find. The Hope Bear’s eyes are closed, and its hands are clasped. This Beanie Baby was caught at a prayerful moment, making it significant as well as a great treasure for collectors. An uncommon 1998 Beanie Baby with a mismatched tag can fetch up to $15,000.

9. Brownie the Bear: $20,000

The inclusion of Brownie the Bear in the top 10 most expensive Beanie Babies is hardly surprising. One of the first nine Beanie Babies ever produced was named Brownie. These Ty Beanie Babies are extremely hard to find since the original line was discontinued in 1993. For an authentic Brownie to be part of their collection, avid collectors will spend up to $20,000.

Read More On: 8 Best Robotics for Kids

8. Millennium Bear: $30,000

It makes sense that a company that gained popularity in the middle of the 1990s would introduce an iconic bear to mark the start of the new millennium. The beat Millennium has a gold ribbon around his neck and is Fuschia in color. This Ty Beanie is perfect for collectors because it features the symbol of a world with a rising sun and 2,000 characters. Up to $30,000 might be spent on first releases in immaculate condition.

7. Valentino Bear: $42,000

Ty Beanie Baby collectors were won over by Valentino when they were introduced in 1995. The white bear wears a red heart patch on its chest and a red ribbon around its neck. Although it started off as a straightforward gift, this Beanie Baby ended up being one of the most priceless. Since it was decommissioned in 1999, this adorable Beanie Baby has grown in value. Rare, authentic Valentino Bears have sold for an astounding $42,000 or more.

6. Lefty Donkey / Righty Elephant: $50,000

Politics is typically not covered by Beanie Babies. However, Ty initially made available their renditions of Lefty the Donkey and Righty the Elephant in 1996. In preparation for the thrilling election in which President Bill Clinton faced off against Republican Bob Dole and Independent Ross Perot, these Beanie Babies were made available. Later on, Lefty the Donkey and Righty the Elephant were both re-released. However, the uncommon 1996 models have sold for $50,000.

5. Jolly the Walrus: $75,000

Jolly the Walrus wasn’t introduced until 1997, yet today they are among the most costly Ty Beanie Babies available. Before being phased out in 1998, the first-generation Jolly’s were only offered for a single year. It may look endearing to have full whiskers, tiny beaded eyes, and a grayish-brown body. Yet this unique Beanie Baby might be worth $75,000!

4. Batty: $125,000

In October 1997, Ty released the Batty Beanie Baby. He was easily identifiable thanks to the velcro strips that were put onto his wings. He is still the only Beanie Baby sold in this manner as of today. It’s possible that Stellaluna, a great children’s novel that came out four years prior, had some influence on Batty’s success. Batty versions that were retired had tag mistakes. The rare Batty Beanie Babies that some lucky collectors possess might be valued up to $125,000.

3. Piccadilly Attic: $125,000

Ty’s Beanie Babies range includes lots of bears in it. Even some of the most ardent Beanie Baby collectors might not have seen Piccadilly Attic, though. One of the most expensive and uncommon Beanie Babies available is Piccadilly Attic. This unusual bear has a clown-like appearance. A traditional red nose and a garment with a vivid green and blue pattern are present. Rare, retired 1993 Piccadilly Attic bears can fetch up to $125,000 on the open market.

Read More On: 8 Best Tablets for Kids

2. Bubbles the Fish: $129,000

Who would have thought that a Beanie Baby with a fish with yellow and black stripes would be more valuable than some of the most costly women’s shoes in the entire world? Ty released Bubbles the Fish in 1995, and he retired from public appearances in 1997. There are listings for original 1995 Bubbles the Fish Beanie Babies with tag faults for as much as $129,000.

1. Princess Bear: $500,000

The most costly Beanie Baby is Ty’s, Princess Bear. The Princess Bear—also referred to as the Princess Diana Bear—was made available in October 1997. Princess Bears have an emblem of a white rose and a purple ribbon that is deep purple. But the release in question was pretty unique. Only a dozen bears remained from the beginning.

For the most affluent Ty Beanie Baby collectors, the bears in the exceedingly limited edition are a dream come true. Unfortunately, only the rare, original release is subject to the $500,000 price tag. The value of the first 200 bears is still $50,000, though, if they are in immaculate condition.

FAQs

Which Beanie Babies are the most expensive?

Princess the Bear, Bubbles the Fish, and Piccadilly Attic is the Beanie Babies that are most valuable. The most money may be made from retiring original Beanie Babies. They are in excellent immaculate condition and with tags.

What are the top ten Beanie Babies in terms of value?

The top 10 most expensive Beanie Babies include Princess the Bear, Bubbles the Fish, Piccadilly Attic, Batty, Jolly the Walrus, Lefty the Donkey and Righty the Elephant, Millennium Bear, Valentino Bear, Brownie the Bear, and Hope Bear.

How can I tell if my Beanie Babies are worth the money?

Rare and limited edition Beanie Babies are the most expensive ones. Bears make up a large portion of them. Your Beanie Babies are more likely to be valuable if they are in excellent shape. See our ranking to find the top 20 Beanie Babies ever sold.

Read More On: 10 Best Electric Cars For Kids

Who is the owner of the most expensive Beanie Baby?

Large Wallace and a group of more Beanie Babies were purchased for $600,000 by an unidentified buyer. Along with Cashew and Huggy bears, this Ty Beanie Baby collection also features a sizable Wallace Beanie Baby. Princess the Bear, based on the late Lady Diana, is the most expensive single Beanie Baby.

Affiliate Disclosure: Purchases that are made using our links may earn us commissions from affiliate partners such as Amazon and other retailers.

Leave a Comment!